How we rate food and products
Open rules: how the Petwert ingredient check works, where the data comes from and why commissions play no role.
1. Where the food data comes from
Ingredient lists come from Open Pet Food Facts, an open database maintained by volunteers (ODbL licence). We only include foods with a name, an identifiable species and an ingredient list of at least three ingredients. The data is reloaded regularly. Recipes change – the pack is always what counts.
2. How the ingredient check works
Each food starts at 6 points. Points are added e.g. for a clearly named animal ingredient first (dog, cat, ferret), a high declared meat share, a single protein source, taurine for cats, hay first for rabbits and guinea pigs. Points are deducted for sugar, colourants, synthetic antioxidants, vague collective terms, plant main ingredients for carnivores, animal ingredients for herbivores and toxic ingredients. This gives a score from 1 to 10. Purely rule-based – no AI, no paid placements.
3. Allergies: strict by design
If you enter an allergy, we hide foods that contain it according to the list. Foods with vague terms such as “poultry” or “meat and animal derivatives” are flagged because the species isn’t known. Gluten covers wheat, barley, rye and spelt.
4. Products from eBay
For each product type we load new buy-it-now offers through the official eBay API. We only show sellers with at least 97 % positive feedback and 50 ratings, remove duplicates and move top-rated sellers and well-reviewed products slightly up. Prices are dated snapshots. Which product type suits your pet is decided by our rules (likes, fears, traits, age, size) – not by price or commission.
5. What we don’t do
We don’t invent ratings, prices or test results, don’t write AI texts about products and don’t give diagnoses. The ingredient check rates the list, not how your pet tolerates it – with illness or suspected allergies, your vet decides.
6. Price per kilo and per day: how we calculate
The price per kilo is the eBay price including shipping divided by the amount in the listing title (e.g. “12 × 400 g”); if the amount is unclear, we show no price per kilo. For the price per day we estimate the energy content with the modified Atwater factors (NRC 2006: 3.5 kcal per gram of protein and carbohydrate, 8.5 kcal per gram of fat) from the analysis on the pack, otherwise with typical values for the food type. Daily needs are calculated for reference animals (cat 4 kg; dog 8, 18 or 32 kg, adult, normally active). It is a comparison value – age, activity and neutering change the need. The feeding guide on the pack and your vet’s advice take priority.